Not just L.A., the City of Angels Is Everywhere
From 2017, read Transcripts documenting the coup interviews with Malcolm Nance

Home of The Covid-19 Transcripts and The Heating Planet Project
Funded by readers through PayPal, available for all to read

Wednesday, November 12, 2025

Tipping Point science- PBS Terra video w transcript, Heating Planet blog-

AMOC, permafrost, coral reefs- many climate systems begin to tip at 1.5 degrees C global warming, a threshold our planet has crossed for an entire calendar year. AMOC is a main reasons Western Europe is so mild. WATCH & READ Oct 23 2025 report We Just Crossed Our FIRST Tipping Point… And It’s NOT What You Think[RELATED POST: https://cityofangels25.blogspot.com/2025/11/tipping-point-definitions-global.html 'tipping point defined]

***
TRANSCRIPT

Tipping points- if you're familiar with this term, you know it usually means disaster. Sudden irreversible shifts like the breakdown of entire ecosystems, the melting of ice sheets, the collapse of major ocean currents that regulate our weather. The list goes on and on. - It's horrific to imagine. 

It's almost an unimaginable humanitarian catastrophe. That's a billion people or more. 

And many of these climate systems could likely begin to tip at 1.5 degrees Celsius of global warming, a threshold that for the first time in human history, our planet has crossed for an entire calendar year. So today we'll explore the tipping points scientists are most worried about. Reveal the one that's already here and see how it's already beginning to change our world. 

Like so many creators, Weathered was hit hard by Congress's decision to defund PBS. But we're not going anywhere. If you believe in independent, fact-checked storytelling about the impacts and solutions to climate change, the best way to support us right now is by grabbing some stylish Weathered gear. So follow the link below to our store. 

1.18

There's a common idea that human psychology is to blame for our lack of climate action, specifically something called psychological distance. The theory goes that because climate change feels distant or unfolds gradually, people don't feel motivated to act. But this might not actually be true. In fact, surveys show the opposite. 76% of Americans say that climate change is already affecting their daily lives. 

Ironically, the greatest risk from climate change may come from the opposite problem, that it does not always unfold gradually. Sometimes the shift from one state to another happens suddenly, and by the time we notice it may already be too late. - 

Change becomes usually more rapid and much harder to reverse. And sometimes it does manifest as a quite distinct shock. 

And this is what makes tipping points so risky. They can suddenly tip and then that rapid change in the system becomes self-propelling. 

2.12

And that means even like a, a small change makes a big difference for the for the system. - 

And our decision making tools don't adequately factor in these state shifts. The 2025 tipping points report highlights that tipping points present distinct governance challenges compared to other aspects of climate change. Changes in these large climate systems often accelerate compound and then suddenly they tip. And that's what makes these tipping points so different from most everyday risks. They're non-linear so it's difficult to understand and plan for - 

If once they're underway, they're hard to reverse. We should be really erring on the side of caution and trying to avoid getting into that situation. Right. - 

And because they're often impossible to undo, at least on human timescales, it's important that we understand tipping points the best we can. But the challenge is that even though scientists can estimate when a system will tip with models known as tipping ranges, we don't know exactly when a system will tip in the real world.

3.14

It isn't always obvious immediately when we've crossed a tipping point because different systems have their different time scales for our human perception. And some systems like melting down an ice sheet are still relatively slow by human perception, whereas other things like having a monsoon or not having a monsoon are really fast.

It's like walking in the dark near a cliff. You don't know you've crossed the edge until you're already falling. So which of earth's tipping points should we be most worried about and what happens when we cross them? Well, there are a couple different ways to understand the risk from tipping points. So let's start by looking at which ones have the highest impact on the world and civilization. So let's start with the AMOC or the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation. - 

What the AMOC, as we call it, is doing is transferring us almost unimaginably large amount of heat across the equator. - 

You can think of the AMOC as a giant heat conveyor belt moving warm surface water north and cold deep water south. It's one of the main reasons Western Europe is so mild. Without it winters there would become dramatically colder on the order of five to 10 degrees Celsius lower in many places. London could feel more like present day northern Canada in the winter. And sea ice could reach as far south as the UK and parts of mainland Europe. 

4.37

And as we warm beyond 1.5 degrees, we move further into the AMOC's tipping range. And the AMOC also affects another important climate system, the position of the Inter-tropical Convergence Zone, which is responsible for the monsoon season in India and West Africa. - 

When you don't have this massive transfer of heat by the ocean circulation, you shift that whole band of rainfall to the south. - 

That could mean a failed monsoon season in India and West Africa threatening food security and water supply for an entire region. - 

If the rains fail and that's it, you know, the monsoon never comes back. It's horrific to imagine. It's almost an unimaginable humanitarian catastrophe. That's a billion people or more. - 

But the Indian and West African monsoons aren't the only tipping points an AMOC collapse could help trigger. - 

And we know it connects up the whole climate system making it more likely to tip the loss of the West Antarctic ice sheet and parts of the East Antarctica sheet. Because a load of heat has got left behind in the southern ocean. - 

5.45

West Antarctica is far more vulnerable and alone holds enough ice to raise global sea levels by about five meters. East Antarctica holds another 58 meters potential rise. The consequences of even a fraction of that melt would be catastrophic. So the AMOC is the tipping point that Tim believes probably has the greatest consequences on its own. But there are other tipping points that may be cause for even greater concern because they're likely much closer to tipping. 

Take permafrost for example. It's frozen ground. Layers of soil, rock, and ice-rich sediment that locks away an enormous amount of carbon. In fact, Arctic permafrost holds roughly twice as much as what's currently in the atmosphere. As the Arctic warms scientists are increasingly worried that parts of this frozen landscape could thaw abruptly releasing massive amounts of greenhouse gases and triggering further warming in a dangerous feedback loop. - 

We're also seeing in the permafrost, in the high Arctic kind of craters and lakes forming and evidence of bits of the permafrost, at least thawing abruptly. And the big question is, is that gonna escalate in scale? - 

But that isn't the only system that's entering its tipping range. - 

Then there's two big eye sheets, both Greenland and West Antarctica where we're struggling to rule out that they're not past the tipping point. - 

Since they're these large, slow systems, they're difficult for scientists to monitor. But regardless, the signs are concerning, especially for West Antarctica. But there's one more system that scientists are even more immediately worried about. - 

7.27

At the moment we are thinking that warm water coral reefs may have passed a tipping point. We are temporarily at like 1.5 degrees centigrade global warming, and the experts had estimated that their tipping point could be at like . degrees centigrade, global warming and kind of consistent with that. We're seeing this just unprecedented extreme dieback of reefs. - 

And even if we act fast, 70 to 90% of coral reefs could die in the coming decades without any action. It's nearly all of them

So each one of these climate systems could completely change if they tipped, and many of them are already within their tipping ranges. But there's one tipping point that nearly all scientists I've spoken with agree that we've almost certainly already crossed and it could change everything. When Tim popularized climate tipping points in his2008 paper, he wasn't just talking about these big scary climate tipping points like the collapse of the AMOC and the death of coral reefs. He was also talking about another kind of tipping point, positive ones. - 

8.38

When I started telling the world about the climate tipping points nearly  years ago, I kind of knew the potential for the positive tipping points, but we were so far away. But what we've seen in recent years is they start to arrive and then it's much more persuasive. - 

And according to Tim, renewable energy has almost certainly passed a positive tipping point. And it's not just Tim who believes this, the UN agrees as well. - 

It's the cheapest form of new power generation in most of the world now. - 

So far, solar power has followed a pattern known as Wright's Law. The idea that technology becomes cheaper as we build more of it. In fact, every time global solar capacity doubles, cost falls by roughly. This steady decline is one of the main reasons solar has become the cheapest source of electricity in much of the world - Today, you know, % of the capacity, electricity capacity being built in the US and worldwide is clean energy

In about half the world, it makes economic sense to shut down an existing fossil fuel power station with good life left in it and replace it with brand new renewables and battery storage. - 

And that shift isn't just happening in wealthy countries. Places that haven't had reliable electricity are now importing more solar than ever before. - 

We've got the cheapest electricity ever and it's just starting to give access to electricity to people who've never had it. 

END OF TRANSCRIPT [They continue to talk about Renewables and investment in Renewables until the end of the video.]


And if you're familiar with this term, 0:07 you know it usually means disaster. 0:09 Sudden irreversible shifts like the breakdown 0:12 of entire ecosystems, the melting of ice sheets, 0:15 the collapse of major ocean currents 0:17 that regulate our weather. 0:19 The list goes on and on. 0:20 - It's horrific to imagine. It's almost an unimaginable 0:23 humanitarian catastrophe. That's a billion people or more. 0:27 - And many of these climate systems could likely begin 0:29 to tip at 1.5 degrees Celsius of global warming, a threshold 0:34 that for the first time in human history, 0:36 our planet has crossed for an entire calendar year. 0:40 So today we'll explore the tipping points scientists are 0:43 most worried about. 0:44 Reveal the one that's already here 0:47 and see how it's already beginning to change our world. 0:55 Like so many creators, Weathered was hit hard 0:58 by Congress's decision to defund PBS. 1:01 But we're not going anywhere. 1:03 If you believe in independent, fact-checked storytelling 1:06 about the impacts and solutions to climate change, 1:09 the best way to support us right now is 1:12 by grabbing some stylish Weathered gear. 1:15 So follow the link below to our store. 1:17 There's a common idea that human psychology is to blame 1:21 for our lack of climate action, 1:23 specifically something called psychological distance. 1:26 The theory goes that because climate change feels distant 1:29 or unfolds gradually, people don't feel motivated to act. 1:33 But this might not actually be true. 1:35 In fact, surveys show the opposite. 1:37 76% of Americans say 1:39 that climate change is already affecting their daily lives. 1:43 Ironically, the greatest risk from climate change may come 1:46 from the opposite problem, 1:47 that it does not always unfold gradually. 1:50 Sometimes the shift from one state 1:52 to another happens suddenly, 1:54 and by the time we notice it may already be too late. 1:57 - Change becomes usually more rapid 2:00 and much harder to reverse. 2:01 And sometimes it does manifest as a quite distinct shock. 2:06 - And this is what makes tipping points so risky. 2:08 They can suddenly tip 2:10 and then that rapid change in the system 2:12 becomes self-propelling. 2:14 - And that means even like a, 2:16 a small change makes a big difference 2:18 for the for the system. 2:19 - And our decision making tools don't adequately factor in 2:22 these state shifts. 2:24 The 2025 tipping points report highlights 2:26 that tipping points present distinct governance challenges 2:30 compared to other aspects of climate change. 2:33 Changes in these large climate systems often accelerate 2:36 compound and then suddenly they tip. 2:39 And that's what makes these tipping points 2:41 so different from most everyday risks. 2:43 They're non-linear so it's difficult 2:46 to understand and plan for 2:48 - If once they're underway, they're hard to reverse. 2:50 We should be really erring on the side of caution 2:52 and trying to avoid getting into that situation. Right. 2:55 - And because they're often impossible to undo, 2:58 at least on human timescales, it's important 3:00 that we understand tipping points the best we can. 3:03 But the challenge is that even though scientists can 3:06 estimate when a system will tip with models known 3:08 as tipping ranges, 3:10 we don't know exactly when a system will 3:12 tip in the real world. 3:13 - It isn't always obvious immediately when we've crossed a 3:16 tipping point because different systems have their different 3:19 time scales for our human perception. 3:21 And some systems like melting down an ice sheet are still 3:25 relatively slow by human perception, 3:28 whereas other things like having a monsoon 3:30 or not having a monsoon are really fast. 3:34 - It's like walking in the dark near a cliff. 3:37 You don't know you've crossed the edge 3:39 until you're already falling. 3:41 So which 3:42 of earth's tipping points should we be most worried about 3:46 and what happens when we cross them? 3:48 Well, there are a couple different ways 3:49 to understand the risk from tipping points. 3:52 So let's start by looking at which ones have the highest 3:55 impact on the world and civilization. 3:58 So let's start with the AMOC 4:00 or the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation. 4:03 - What the AMOC, as we call it, 4:05 is doing is transferring us almost unimaginably large amount 4:09 of heat across the equator. 4:11 - You can think of the AMOC 4:12 as a giant heat conveyor belt moving warm surface water 4:15 north and cold deep water south. 4:18 It's one of the main reasons Western Europe is so mild. 4:21 Without it winters there would become dramatically colder on 4:25 the order of five 4:26 to 10 degrees Celsius lower in many places. London could feel 4:30 more like present day northern Canada in the winter. 4:33 And sea ice could reach as far south as the UK 4:37 and parts of mainland Europe. 4:38 And as we warm beyond 1.5 degrees, 4:41 we move further into the AMOC's tipping range. 4:44 And the AMOC also affects another important climate system, 4:48 the position of the Inter-tropical Convergence Zone, 4:51 which is responsible 4:53 for the monsoon season in India and West Africa. 4:56 - When you don't have this massive transfer of heat 4:59 by the ocean circulation, you shift that whole band 5:02 of rainfall to the south. 5:04 - That could mean a failed monsoon season in India 5:07 and West Africa threatening food security 5:10 and water supply for an entire region. 5:13 - If the rains fail 5:14 and that's it, you know, the monsoon never comes back. 5:17 It's horrific to imagine. It's almost an unimaginable 5:20 humanitarian catastrophe. That's a billion people or more. 5:26 - But the Indian and West African monsoons aren't the only 5:29 tipping points an AMOC collapse could help trigger. 5:32 - And we know it connects up the whole climate system making 5:35 it more likely to tip the loss 5:37 of the West Antarctic ice sheet 5:39 and parts of the East Antarctica sheet. 5:41 Because a load of heat has got left 5:42 behind in the southern ocean. 5:44 - West Antarctica is far more vulnerable 5:47 and alone holds enough ice to raise global sea levels 5:51 by about five meters. 5:53 East Antarctica holds another 58 meters potential rise. 5:59 The consequences of even a fraction of 6:02 that melt would be catastrophic. 6:05 So the AMOC is the tipping point 6:07 that Tim believes probably has the greatest 6:09 consequences on its own. 6:11 But there are other tipping points that may be cause 6:14 for even greater concern 6:16 because they're likely much closer to tipping. 6:19 Take permafrost for example. It's frozen ground. Layers 6:23 of soil, rock, 6:24 and ice-rich sediment 6:25 that locks away an enormous amount of carbon. 6:29 In fact, Arctic permafrost holds roughly twice as much 6:33 as what's currently in the atmosphere. 6:35 As the Arctic warms scientists are increasingly worried 6:38 that parts of this frozen landscape could thaw abruptly 6:42 releasing massive amounts of greenhouse gases 6:45 and triggering further warming in a dangerous feedback loop. 6:48 - We're also seeing in the permafrost, 6:50 in the high Arctic kind of craters and lakes forming 6:54 and evidence of bits of the permafrost, 6:57 at least thawing abruptly. 6:58 And the big question is, is that gonna escalate in scale? 7:01 - But that isn't the only system 7:03 that's entering its tipping range. 7:05 - Then there's two big eye sheets, both Greenland 7:08 and West Antarctica where we're struggling to rule out 7:11 that they're not past the tipping point. 7:14 - Since they're these large, slow systems, they're difficult 7:18 for scientists to monitor. 7:19 But regardless, the signs are concerning, especially 7:22 for West Antarctica. 7:23 But there's one more system 7:25 that scientists are even more immediately worried about. 7:28 - At the moment we are thinking 7:30 that warm water coral reefs may have passed a tipping point. 7:35 We are temporarily at like 1.5 degrees centigrade global 7:38 warming, and the experts had estimated 7:41 that their tipping point could be at like 1.2 degrees 7:43 centigrade, global warming and kind of consistent with that. 7:46 We're seeing this just unprecedented extreme 7:49 dieback of reefs. 7:53 - And even if we act fast, 70 to 90% 7:56 of coral reefs could die in the coming decades 7:58 without any action. 7:59 It's nearly all of them. 8:02 So each one 8:03 of these climate systems could completely change if they 8:07 tipped, and many 8:08 of them are already within their tipping ranges. 8:11 But there's one tipping point 8:12 that nearly all scientists I've spoken with agree 8:15 that we've almost certainly already crossed 8:18 and it could change everything. 8:20 When Tim popularized climate tipping points in his 2008 8:24 paper, he wasn't just talking about these big scary climate 8:27 tipping points like the collapse of the AMOC 8:30 and the death of coral reefs. 8:31 He was also talking about another kind 8:34 of tipping point, positive ones. 8:35 - When I started telling the world about the climate 8:38 tipping points nearly 20 years ago, I kind 8:40 of knew the potential for the positive tipping points, 8:43 but we were so far away. 8:45 But what we've seen in recent years is they start to arrive 8:48 and then it's much more persuasive. 8:51 - And according to Tim, 8:52 renewable energy has almost certainly passed a 8:55 positive tipping point. 8:56 And it's not just Tim who believes this, 8:58 the UN agrees as well. 9:00 - It's the cheapest form 9:01 of new power generation in most of the world now. 9:05 - So far, solar power has followed a pattern known 9:08 as Wright's Law. The idea that technology becomes cheaper 9:12 as we build more of it. 9:13 In fact, solar has shown a learning rate of about 20%, 9:17 meaning that every time global solar capacity doubles, cost 9:21 falls by roughly 20%. 9:24 This steady decline is one 9:25 of the main reasons solar has become the cheapest source 9:28 of electricity in much of the world 9:31 - Today, 9:32 you know, 90% of the capacity, 9:33 electricity capacity being built in the US 9:36 and worldwide is clean energy. 9:38 - Since 1976, the cost 9:41 of solar has dropped over 99%. 9:44 In 2024 alone, solar costs dropped by 35% 9:48 and battery components fell by as much as 54%. 9:51 - In about half the world, it makes economic sense 9:55 to shut down an existing fossil fuel power station 9:58 with good life left in it 10:00 and replace it with brand new renewables 10:02 and battery storage. 10:03 - And that shift isn't just happening in wealthy countries. 10:06 Places that haven't had reliable electricity are now 10:09 importing more solar than ever before. 10:12 - We've got the cheapest electricity ever 10:15 and it's just starting to give access to electricity 10:18 to people who've never had it. 10:20 600 million of whom are in Sub-Saharan Africa. 10:22 - Solar adoption in Africa skyrocketed between June 2024 10:27 and 2025. 10:28 Imports rose by 60% 10:30 with 20 countries buying record amounts of solar panels. 10:34 And we're seeing similar surges across the globe. 10:36 - But even countries that are more functional like India 10:38 have really seen a, a dramatic expansion of 10:40 of solar energy in recent years 10:42 because it is so much cheaper than everything else. 10:44 - And this growth is occurring across a number 10:46 of sectors of renewables. 10:48 - Some big sectors are, are closer 10:50 to the tipping point than others and 10:52 and actually one positive tipping point can bring forward 10:55 the next, which is kind of cool. 10:57 - So yes, the progress is mind blowing. 10:59 Renewables are scaling faster, 11:01 electrification is increasing, and efficiency is improving, 11:05 and fossil fuels are projected to decline. 11:08 But despite all of this news experts say this change needs 11:12 to happen much faster 11:14 because we don't know exactly when we will cross these 11:16 climate tipping points. 11:18 So every fraction of a degree matters. 11:20 And that is scary, 11:22 especially given the recent rise in petrostates doubling 11:25 down on oil and gas. 11:27 I mean, globally, 11:28 fossil fuel subsidies are almost nine times higher for oil 11:32 and gas than for renewables. 11:34 So even though we've crossed a crucial positive tipping 11:37 point that could help us avoid the worst impacts 11:40 of these devastating climate tipping points, 11:42 the risk remains that it might not happen fast enough. 11:46 But regardless, there might still be some hope. 11:48 - But while I think the US is definitely gonna be moving 11:50 backwards or certainly slowing down our decarbonization 11:54 pretty dramatically in the next four years, 11:56 I don't think the same is true for the rest of the world. 11:58 - Many countries are taking advantage of the opportunity 12:01 to compete in the renewables space. 12:03 - China's on track to potentially peak its emissions as early 12:06 as this year and start declining. 12:08 So that's, you know, really good climate news. 12:10 - They manufacture over 80% of solar panels, 12:13 about 75% of EV batteries 12:16 and 60% of wind turbines globally. 12:20 They're on track to become the world's first electrostate, 12:23 meaning they're the largest deployer 12:26 and producer of renewables. 12:27 And with the renewables tipping point crossed petrostates 12:31 will inevitably fall behind. 12:33 - China is becoming the world's first electrostate while 12:35 the US is doubling down on being a petrostate. 12:37 Since now we are the world's largest oil producer 12:40 and world's largest gas exporter. 12:42 We are doubling down on the technologies the 21st century, 12:45 and we really risk being left behind. 12:47 - So what's the takeaway here? 12:49 Well, we aren't necessarily doomed, 12:52 but we are in a battle of the tipping points, a race 12:55 between climate change and clean renewable energy. 12:58 We're at a critical moment 13:00 where if we invest enough resources into renewables, 13:04 we could tip into a cleaner, safer, healthier future. 13:08 Anyway, I'd love to hear from you on this topic. 13:11 Which tipping points are you most concerned with 13:15 and are there any renewable technologies 13:17 that you're particularly excited about? 13:19 Let us know in the comments 13:21 and see you next time on Weathered.

No comments:

Post a Comment